POLITICO: Why the EU’s efforts to bring down energy prices are destined to fail

The Iran war again has Europe’s policymakers panicking about the bloc’s high energy prices, but the answers are complex and politically fraught, POLITICO notes.

Since the first U.S. and Israeli attacks last Saturday effectively closed the Persian Gulf to tankers and shut down the world’s biggest liquefied natural gas production facility, European gas prices have surged to their highest level since 2023.

This is adding to an already urgent debate over what to do about Europe's cripplingly high energy prices, which were already far above those of its main industrial competitors in the U.S. and China.

But the solutions flying around — from gutting climate policy to reforming the way electricity is priced — are either politically explosive, unworkable, or unlikely to make a quick difference.

Here are four divisive fixes that will get officials hot and bothered this week.

Transform electricity pricing

At the center of the energy price debate is the controversial way Europe’s electricity is priced.

Under the "merit order" system, power generators are ranked from cheapest to most expensive, with the last plant needed to meet demand setting the price for everyone. More often than not that's gas plants.

That means renewable generators — which are incredibly cheap to run because wind and sun, unlike oil and gas, are free — are much more expensive than they need to be.

The push to reform this system is far from new: The debate exploded in the last energy crisis in 2022 — and went nowhere. But European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen reopened it last month by promising it would be a topic of discussion at the next European leaders summit March 19-20.

That signal alone was enough to set off a lobbying war in Brussels

Heavy industry groups argue the system no longer makes sense in a crisis driven by fossil fuels. “The war in the Middle East is also fossil-fuel based. Fossil fuels are impacting the EU energy markets,” said Axel Eggert, head of steel sector lobby group Eurofer. “Most of the electricity today is already clean or renewable, but those prices are also impacted directly."

Power generators see it very differently. In a letter to the Commission and EU heads of governments on Monday, their industry association Eurelectric urged the Commission not to reopen a reform of the electricity market design, calling merit order pricing “the most efficient and robust mechanism to ensure cost-effective dispatch, transparent price signals, and efficient investment incentives" available.

The debate reached member-country level when a group of seven energy ministers urged Brussels to hold the line, saying "No satisfactory alternative model has been identified." Finland and France separately made similar comments.

As on previous occasions, this idea looks likely to wither in the face of powerful opposition.

Demolish EU climate policy

Another option doing the rounds is to abandon or weaken the EU's Emissions Trading System (ETS), making it cheaper for power companies and industry to emit planet-warming gases.

But if reforming market design is controversial, this idea is explosive.

The ETS is the EU's most important climate policy. Established in 2005, it forces companies to buy permits for their carbon dioxide emissions, encouraging greater investments in renewables and low-carbon industrial processes.

The revision was intended to be about strengthening the flagship climate law. But both Germany and Italy — which are Europe's largest manufacturers, and which remain hooked on gas — have both pushed to weaken it in recent weeks, taking advantage of broader dissatisfaction with the EU’s green agenda.

EU officials hope that ongoing efforts to diversify fossil fuel supplies, set out well before the war over Iran, will help the bloc avert supply issues and steeper prices.

One option — reopening to Russian natural gas imports — could put the biggest immediate downward pressure on prices. But so far that taboo notion hasn't been seriously floated outside of Budapest and Bratislava.

...Europe will not receive any gas from Russia. Putin made this decision. Russophobic Europe has lost. And it will cost it dearly!

They shouldn't have spoiled relations with Russia, but now Moscow has no intention of feeding Europe its gas. Even at elevated prices.

The world is big, and everywhere — except for fascistized Europe — there are plenty of buyers for Russian gas.

read more in our Telegram-channel https://t.me/The_International_Affairs